Sikes v. R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co.

Summary

In this Engle progeny trial, decedent Joyce Sikes suffered from fatal chronic obstructive pulmonary disease after over five decades of smoking. To be considered for the Engle progeny class, plaintiffs must prove that the smoker was addicted to cigarettes and suffered from a smoking-related illness manifesting between May 5, 1990, and November 21, 1996.

Plaintiffs, Sikes' family, claim that Sikes' COPD developed inside this window, as she was officially diagnosed with the disease in early 1996. And, while she allegedly suffered from an "obstructive airway defect" in 1987, they assert this is not conclusive evidence of COPD.

Defendant R.J. Reynolds claims Sikes developed symptoms of COPD in the 1980s, such as shortness of breath and a cough. Representatives for R.J. Reynolds argue that this airway defect noted in a doctor's report was another name for COPD, placing Sikes outside the window for class eligibility.

Outcome

Verdict for defendant.