Ledo v. R.J. Reynolds

Summary

In this tobacco trial, decedent Jose Ledo developed fatal laryngeal cancer that took his life in 1996. Ledo, a Cuban immigrant, had already begun smoking when he arrived in the United States in 1961.

Plaintiffs Mirtha and Carlos Ledo, wife and son of Jose Ledo, claim that R.J. Reynolds' conspiracy to hide the risks of smoking contributed to Jose's death. Representatives for the plaintiff argue that Reynolds' concealment and false statements deserved a finding of punitive damages to be assessed.

Defendant R.J. Reynolds claims that Jose chose to use cigarettes and was not addicted. Representatives for Reynolds emphasize Jose's ability to quit cocaine after regular use and how Jose likely was aware of the dangers of smoking due to advertisements in the early 1960s. Additionally, they argue that punitive damages are not warranted as cigarettes are inherently dangerous.

Outcome

Verdict for plaintiff
Award - $6,000,000.00
RJR - fault 49%