Hoffman v. Philip Morris

Summary

In this tobacco trial, decedent Robert Hoffman smoked Philip Morris' cigarettes for years, since he was a teenager. Despite quitting smoking before 30, he developed lung cancer and died at 46.

His family argues that his lung cancer resulted from his smoking, as their doctors agree that the cancer was an adenocarcinoma, which is often caused by smoking.

Defendant Philip Morris argues that his cancer was likely not caused by smoking, as it developed 15 years after he quit. Instead, the company's attorneys suggest other causes, such as mesothelioma, that were considered by treating providers.

Outcome

Verdict for plaintiff.
Total damages: $5 million

Apportionment of fault:
Philip Morris: 60%
Robert Hoffman: 40%