Evans v. Pacific Steel Casting Company

VERDICT

Trial
03/20/12 – 04/11/12

Summary

In this environmental tort litigation proceeding, Plaintiff Rosie Lee Evans and other 170 joining plaintiffs alleged Pacific Steel Casting Company of being negligent and causing nuisance by contamination through emissions from a PSC casting plant run by the company in the vicinity of residences of the plaintiffs.

Plaintiff and other joining plaintiffs were represented by attorney Timothy Rumberger. The defendant in this case, Pacific Steel Casting Company was represented by attorneys Reuben Castellon and Juliana Kresse.

Outcome

Debra Khattab, one of many plaintiffs was the only party to recover damages from Pacific Steel. Defendants won on all other claims.

SESSIONS WITH Jan Null

AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
33 Chapters
DescriptionAttorneyWitnessPresence
00:00:00General Case Activities
00:00:46Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyBuford, George In Person
00:13:53Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenBuford, George In Person
00:30:23Witness Re-Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyBuford, George In Person
00:30:53General Case Activities
00:31:50General Case Activities
00:32:14Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyLemus, Rodrigo Other
00:45:28Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenLemus, Rodrigo In Person
00:51:09General Case Activities
00:51:49Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyRenaudin, Sebastien In Person
01:10:41Break
01:24:23Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenRenaudin, Sebastien In Person
01:35:06Witness Re-Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyRenaudin, Sebastien In Person
01:35:37General Case Activities
01:36:15Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothySerrano- Crenshaw, Christyna In Person
02:06:15Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenSerrano- Crenshaw, Christyna In Person
02:18:38Witness Re-Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothySerrano- Crenshaw, Christyna In Person
02:20:18Witness Re-Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenSerrano- Crenshaw, Christyna In Person
02:20:52General Case Activities
02:22:05Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyNull, Jan In Person
02:45:39Break
02:59:10Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyNull, Jan In Person
03:05:58Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenNull, Jan In Person
03:27:11Witness Re-Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyNull, Jan In Person
03:32:19Witness Re-Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenNull, Jan In Person
03:32:56Witness Re-Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyNull, Jan In Person
03:33:54Witness Re-Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenNull, Jan In Person
03:34:15General Case Activities
03:36:13Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyShusterman, Dr. Dennis M.D.In Person
03:50:37Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenShusterman, Dr. Dennis M.D.In Person
04:13:07Witness Re-Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyShusterman, Dr. Dennis M.D.In Person
04:18:04Witness Re-Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenShusterman, Dr. Dennis M.D.In Person
04:19:31End of Session
MAR
22
AM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
MAR
23
AM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
MAR
26
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
32 Chapters
DescriptionAttorneyWitnessPresence
00:00:00General Case Activities
00:00:43Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyStevenson, Eric In Person
00:43:34Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenStevenson, Eric In Person
01:02:12Witness Re-Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyStevenson, Eric In Person
01:04:16Witness Re-Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenStevenson, Eric In Person
01:04:25General Case Activities
01:05:14Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenWood, L A In Person
01:29:50Break
01:46:58Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenWood, L A In Person
01:51:36General Case Activities
01:53:20Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyChernaik, Dr. Mark Ph.D.In Person
02:30:20Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenChernaik, Dr. Mark Ph.D.In Person
02:51:10General Case Activities
02:51:55Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyEvans, Rosie Lee In Person
02:55:52Witness Cross ExaminationKresse, JulianaEvans, Rosie Lee In Person
03:00:24General Case Activities
03:01:06Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyMcCoy, Paul In Person
03:03:17Break
03:23:32Witness Cross ExaminationKresse, JulianaMcCoy, Paul In Person
03:25:35General Case Activities
03:26:20Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothySpencer, Richard In Person
03:28:35Witness Cross ExaminationKresse, JulianaSpencer, Richard In Person
03:30:56General Case Activities
03:31:30Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyLong, Patricia In Person
03:33:45Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenLong, Patricia In Person
03:35:27General Case Activities
03:36:02Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyGardener, Nomi In Person
03:38:08Witness Cross ExaminationKresse, JulianaGardener, Nomi In Person
03:39:30General Case Activities
03:40:19Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothySpector, Gene In Person
04:25:24Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenSpector, Gene In Person
04:39:26End of Session
MAR
28
AM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
27 Chapters
DescriptionAttorneyWitnessPresence
00:00:00General Case Activities
00:00:46Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenSpector, Gene In Person
00:25:15Witness Re-Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothySpector, Gene In Person
00:27:02Witness Re-Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenSpector, Gene In Person
00:28:16Witness Re-Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothySpector, Gene In Person
00:28:29General Case Activities
00:30:32Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyWayne, Lawrence In Person
00:58:29Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenWayne, Lawrence In Person
01:13:51General Case Activities
01:14:05Break
01:31:00General Case Activities
01:31:27Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyCox, Dr. Daniel Ph.D., FIHIn Person
02:27:44Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenCox, Dr. Daniel Ph.D., FIHIn Person
02:52:25General Case Activities
02:54:05Break
03:10:03Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenCox, Dr. Daniel Ph.D., FIHIn Person
03:12:54Witness Re-Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyCox, Dr. Daniel Ph.D., FIHIn Person
03:13:54Witness Re-Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenCox, Dr. Daniel Ph.D., FIHIn Person
03:14:23General Case Activities
03:15:34Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyOfferman, Francis In Person
03:40:15Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenOfferman, Francis In Person
03:51:06General Case Activities
03:52:26Witness Direct ExaminationRumberger, TimothyBridges, Charles In Person
04:10:52Witness Cross ExaminationCastellon, RubenBridges, Charles In Person
04:23:59General Case Activities
04:24:12General Case Activities
04:24:27End of Session
MAR
29
AM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
MAR
30
APR
5
AM Session
Not in Session
0 Chapters
APR
6

Recording Disclaimer: This proceeding was recorded in full.

Suggest a Trial

Want to see a trial that you don't see in our list of upcoming trials?

Suggest a Case

CVN Essentials

The most important and informative moments of each trial

CVN Essentials

Video Library

Unlimited access to thousands of hours of past coverage of high stakes civil litigation

Video Library

  • Follow Us
  • Contact Us
  • 4901 Olde Towne Parkway
  • Suite 100
  • Marietta, GA 30068
  • 877-834-8627
  • 404-935-0321

Copyright 2025 Courtroom Connect.