Beatriz Vergara, et al. v. State of California

Summary

In this education Law proceeding, the plaintiff Beatriz Vergara and others challenged the tenure policies of California public school teachers. The lawsuit was filed on behalf of nine individual public school students. The allegations against the defendants were that ineffective teachers are allowed to continue teaching even though their earlier performance had been inadequate.
Plaintiff Beatriz Vergara and other joining plaintiffs were represented by attorneys Theodore Ted Boutrous and Marcellus McRae. The defense comprises of California Teachers Association and the State of California. California Teachers Association was represented by attorney James Finberg. The State of California was represented by attorneys Nimrod Elias and Susan Carson.

Outcome

The court found that all the challenged statutes were unconstitutional and the injunctions were stayed.

Case Information

Attorneys

Witnesses

Plaintiff: Vergara, Beatriz
Defense: California Teacher's Association
State of California

Judge: Rolf Treu
Jurisdiction: Superior Court of California, Los Angeles
Court: Stanley Mosk Courthouse

Case Number: BC484642
Industry: Education
Practice Area: Education Law

Plaintiff

Vergara, Beatriz

Sessions

Attorney

Witness

Type

Description

AM Session

Openings

6 Chapters

	Description	Attorney
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:03:11	Opening Statement	Boutrous, Theodore "Ted"
00:55:48	Break
01:01:47	Opening Statement	Elias, Nimrod
01:42:26	Opening Statement	Finberg, James
02:03:01	End of Session

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

8 Chapters

JAN

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

4 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Deasy, Dr. John Ph.D.	In Person
00:57:58	Break
01:15:16	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Deasy, Dr. John Ph.D.	In Person
02:26:28	End of Session

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

8 Chapters

JAN

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

6 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Re-Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Deasy, Dr. John Ph.D.	In Person
00:16:34	Witness Re-Cross Examination	Finberg, James	Deasy, Dr. John Ph.D.	In Person
00:23:03	Witness Direct Examination	Boutrous, Theodore "Ted"	Chetty, Dr. Nadarajan	In Person
01:15:56	Break
01:35:26	Witness Direct Examination	Boutrous, Theodore "Ted"	Chetty, Dr. Nadarajan	In Person
02:23:16	Break

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

3 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Cross Examination	Carson, Susan	Deasy, Dr. John Ph.D.	In Person
00:45:21	Witness Re-Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Deasy, Dr. John Ph.D.	In Person
01:08:57	End of Session

JAN

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

5 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Boutrous, Theodore "Ted"	Chetty, Dr. Nadarajan	In Person
01:12:59	Break
01:28:57	Witness Direct Examination	Boutrous, Theodore "Ted"	Chetty, Dr. Nadarajan	In Person
02:13:17	Witness Cross Examination	Finberg, James	Chetty, Dr. Nadarajan	In Person
02:28:33	End of Session

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

12 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Cross Examination	Finberg, James	Chetty, Dr. Nadarajan	In Person
00:19:06	Witness Cross Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Chetty, Dr. Nadarajan	In Person
00:27:32	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Boutrous, Theodore "Ted"	Chetty, Dr. Nadarajan	In Person
00:28:20	General Case Activities
00:45:09	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Adam, Larissa	In Person
01:29:11	Break
01:45:35	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Adam, Larissa	In Person
02:07:05	Witness Cross Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Adam, Larissa	In Person
02:35:25	Witness Cross Examination	Carson, Susan	Adam, Larissa	In Person
02:44:39	Witness Re-Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Adam, Larissa	In Person
02:50:42	Witness Re-Cross Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Adam, Larissa	In Person
02:52:23	End of Session

JAN

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

4 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Christmas, Troy	In Person
00:48:27	Break
01:03:22	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Christmas, Troy	In Person
01:46:14	End of Session

JAN

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

5 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Christmas, Troy	In Person
00:21:06	Witness Cross Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Christmas, Troy	In Person
00:58:26	Break
01:14:47	Witness Cross Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Christmas, Troy	In Person
01:59:31	End of Session

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

9 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Cross Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Christmas, Troy	In Person
01:02:24	Break
01:05:12	Witness Cross Examination	Antonen, Charles	Christmas, Troy	In Person
01:08:24	Witness Re-Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Christmas, Troy	In Person
01:28:36	Break
01:44:19	Witness Re-Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Christmas, Troy	In Person
01:50:44	Witness Re-Cross Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Christmas, Troy	In Person
01:52:41	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Raymond, Jonathan	In Person
02:56:15	End of Session

FEB

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

8 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:01:34	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Raymond, Jonathan	In Person
00:40:42	Witness Cross Examination	Antonen, Charles	Raymond, Jonathan	In Person
00:57:25	Break
01:14:56	Witness Cross Examination	Weissglass, Jonathan	Raymond, Jonathan	In Person
01:29:47	Witness Re-Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Raymond, Jonathan	In Person
01:40:19	Witness Re-Cross Examination	Weissglass, Jonathan	Raymond, Jonathan	In Person
01:41:30	Witness Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Bhatka, Bhavini	In Person
01:50:22	End of Session

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

10 Chapters

FEB

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

5 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Douglas, Mark	In Person
00:54:00	Break
01:10:07	Witness Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Douglas, Mark	In Person
01:26:57	Witness Cross Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Douglas, Mark	In Person
01:59:08	End of Session

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

7 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Cross Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Douglas, Mark	In Person
01:17:38	Witness Cross Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Douglas, Mark	In Person
01:34:33	Break
01:49:39	Witness Cross Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Douglas, Mark	In Person
02:00:55	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Douglas, Mark	In Person
02:38:18	Witness Direct Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Kane, Thomas	In Person
02:54:43	End of Session

FEB

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

4 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Kane, Thomas	In Person
01:13:39	Break
01:30:25	Witness Direct Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Kane, Thomas	In Person
02:29:32	End of Session

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

8 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Kane, Thomas	In Person
00:13:42	Witness Cross Examination	Finberg, James	Kane, Thomas	In Person
01:15:24	Witness Cross Examination	Bunshoft, Jennifer	Kane, Thomas	In Person
01:24:51	Break
01:40:13	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Kane, Thomas	In Person
02:05:13	Witness Re-Cross Examination	Finberg, James	Kane, Thomas	In Person
02:06:30	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Weaver, Kareem	In Person
02:56:47	End of Session

FEB

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

14 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Weaver, Kareem	In Person
00:35:54	General Case Activities
00:36:34	Break
00:47:18	General Case Activities
00:48:26	Witness Cross Examination	Weissglass, Jonathan	Weaver, Kareem	In Person
00:59:50	Witness Cross Examination	Carson, Susan	Weaver, Kareem	In Person
01:05:49	Witness Re-Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Weaver, Kareem	In Person
01:15:07	Break
01:30:12	General Case Activities
01:31:56	Witness Direct Examination	Monagas, Enrique		In Person
01:54:36	Witness Cross Examination	Antonen, Charles	Moss, Jonathan	In Person
01:56:25	Witness Cross Examination	Finberg, James	Moss, Jonathan	In Person
01:58:40	Witness Re-Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Moss, Jonathan	In Person
02:00:14	End of Session

FEB

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

12 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Cross Examination	Thoreen, Peder	Kappenhagen, William	In Person
00:19:58	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Kappenhagen, William	In Person
00:32:55	Witness Re-Cross Examination	Thoreen, Peder	Kappenhagen, William	In Person
00:38:22	Break
00:43:52	Witness Direct Examination	Monagas, Enrique	Pulley, Maggie	In Person
01:10:21	Break
01:29:34	Witness Cross Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Pulley, Maggie	In Person
01:42:53	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Macias, Jose	In Person
01:52:20	Break
01:57:46	General Case Activities
02:05:09	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Macias, Jose	In Person
02:17:38	End of Session

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

6 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Macias, Jose	In Person
00:05:19	Witness Cross Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Macias, Jose	In Person
00:46:15	Witness Cross Examination	Antonen, Charles	Macias, Jose	In Person
00:54:17	Witness Direct Examination	Evangelis, Theane	DeBose, Brandon	In Person
01:11:42	General Case Activities
01:12:22	End of Session

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

2 Chapters

			Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
		00:00:00	Witness Cross Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	DeBose, Brandon	In Person
		00:14:12	End of Session

FEB

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

12 Chapters

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

11 Chapters

FEB

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

13 Chapters

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

6 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Ramanathan, Dr. Arun Ph.D.	In Person
01:24:31	Break
01:40:46	General Case Activities
01:48:41	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Ramanathan, Dr. Arun Ph.D.	In Person
02:41:01	Witness Cross Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Ramanathan, Dr. Arun Ph.D.	In Person
02:57:56	End of Session

FEB

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

7 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Cross Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Ramanathan, Dr. Arun Ph.D.	In Person
00:42:03	Witness Cross Examination	Bunshoft, Jennifer	Ramanathan, Dr. Arun Ph.D.	In Person
01:08:12	Break
01:23:14	Witness Re-Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Ramanathan, Dr. Arun Ph.D.	In Person
02:20:18	Witness Re-Cross Examination	Bunshoft, Jennifer	Ramanathan, Dr. Arun Ph.D.	In Person
02:21:16	General Case Activities
02:25:19	End of Session

FEB

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

4 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Finberg, James	Moore Johnson, Susan	In Person
01:03:08	Break
01:20:40	Witness Direct Examination	Finberg, James	Moore Johnson, Susan	In Person
01:58:32	End of Session

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

8 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Finberg, James	Moore Johnson, Susan	In Person
00:26:46	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Moore Johnson, Susan	In Person
01:13:17	Break
01:29:37	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Moore Johnson, Susan	In Person
01:48:03	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Finberg, James	Moore Johnson, Susan	In Person
02:05:10	General Case Activities
02:08:42	Witness Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Jacobs, Sandi	In Person
02:17:44	End of Session

FEB

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

8 Chapters

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

9 Chapters

FEB

AM Session

Other

2 Chapters

FEB

PM Session

Other

4 Chapters

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

5 Chapters

PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

15 Chapters

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

4 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Finberg, James	Rothstein, Dr. Jesse Ph.D.	In Person
00:54:44	Break
01:10:09	Witness Direct Examination	Finberg, James	Rothstein, Dr. Jesse Ph.D.	In Person
01:41:02	End of Session

PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

6 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Finberg, James	Rothstein, Dr. Jesse Ph.D.	In Person
01:14:38	General Case Activities
01:24:22	Break
01:39:48	Witness Direct Examination	Finberg, James	Rothstein, Dr. Jesse Ph.D.	In Person
02:02:08	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Rothstein, Dr. Jesse Ph.D.	In Person
02:58:48	End of Session

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

6 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Rothstein, Dr. Jesse Ph.D.	In Person
00:40:16	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Finberg, James	Rothstein, Dr. Jesse Ph.D.	In Person
01:02:11	Witness Re-Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Rothstein, Dr. Jesse Ph.D.	In Person
01:03:54	Break
01:19:29	Witness Direct Examination	Hsiao, Constance	Decker, Vickie	In Person
01:56:24	End of Session

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

7 Chapters

PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

6 Chapters

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

5 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Carson, Susan	Mills, Susan	In Person
00:55:03	Break
01:10:54	Witness Direct Examination	Carson, Susan	Mills, Susan	In Person
01:40:24	Witness Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Mills, Susan	In Person
01:53:37	End of Session

PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

14 Chapters

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

6 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Seymour, Jeffery	In Person
00:58:32	Break
01:20:17	Witness Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Seymour, Jeffery	In Person
01:24:34	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Seymour, Jeffery	In Person
01:49:39	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Seymour, Jeffery	In Person
01:53:31	End of Session

PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

10 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Olson-Jones, Betty	In Person
00:55:56	Witness Cross Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Olson-Jones, Betty	In Person
01:10:39	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Olson-Jones, Betty	In Person
01:11:51	General Case Activities
01:13:01	Witness Direct Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Boegman Clark, Theresa	In Person
01:21:00	Break
01:37:32	Witness Direct Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Boegman Clark, Theresa	In Person
02:19:26	Witness Cross Examination	Boutrous, Theodore "Ted"	Boegman Clark, Theresa	In Person
02:25:22	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Boegman Clark, Theresa	In Person
02:28:50	End of Session

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

7 Chapters

PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

10 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Brown, Shannan	In Person
00:05:30	Witness Cross Examination	Thoreen, Peder	Brown, Shannan	In Person
00:10:32	Witness Direct Examination	Antonen, Charles	Davies, Elizabeth	In Person
01:22:26	Break
01:39:41	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Davies, Elizabeth	In Person
01:43:41	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Thoreen, Peder	Davies, Elizabeth	In Person
01:45:29	Witness Direct Examination	Carson, Susan	Raun-Linde, Dr. Peggy Ph.D.	In Person
02:13:20	Witness Cross Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Raun-Linde, Dr. Peggy Ph.D.	In Person
02:24:37	General Case Activities
02:28:19	End of Session

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

8 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Watty, Dawna	In Person
00:42:08	Witness Direct Examination	Hsiao, Constance	Mize, Anthony	In Person
00:59:57	Break
01:16:13	Witness Direct Examination	Hsiao, Constance	Mize, Anthony	In Person
01:39:15	Witness Cross Examination	Monagas, Enrique	Mize, Anthony	In Person
01:41:09	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Hsiao, Constance	Mize, Anthony	In Person
01:45:00	General Case Activities
01:50:57	End of Session

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

6 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Pitts, P. Casey	Tolladay, Linda	In Person
00:45:27	Witness Cross Examination	Withers, Kyle	Tolladay, Linda	In Person
00:50:05	Break
01:07:12	Witness Direct Examination	Carson, Susan	Oropeza, Jeannie	In Person
01:44:27	Witness Cross Examination	Withers, Kyle	Oropeza, Jeannie	In Person
01:44:59	End of Session

PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

15 Chapters

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

5 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Direct Examination	Bunshoft, Jennifer	Berliner, David Ph.D.	In Person
01:01:34	Break
01:17:43	Witness Direct Examination	Bunshoft, Jennifer	Berliner, David Ph.D.	In Person
01:41:15	Witness Cross Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Berliner, David Ph.D.	In Person
01:55:50	End of Session

PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

13 Chapters

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	Witness Cross Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Berliner, David Ph.D.	In Person
00:38:33	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Bunshoft, Jennifer	Berliner, David Ph.D.	In Person
00:43:53	Witness Direct Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Berliner, David Ph.D.	In Person
00:47:35	Witness Cross Examination	Bunshoft, Jennifer	Berliner, David Ph.D.	In Person
00:49:52	Witness Cross Examination	Weissglass, Jonathan	Berliner, David Ph.D.	In Person
00:53:09	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Berliner, David Ph.D.	In Person
00:54:08	Break
00:56:19	Witness Direct Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Nichols, Lynda	In Person
01:11:34	Break
01:28:00	Witness Direct Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Nichols, Lynda	In Person
02:22:21	Witness Direct Examination	Finberg, James	Nichols, Lynda	In Person
02:25:26	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Nichols, Lynda	In Person
02:34:56	End of Session

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

8 Chapters

PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

12 Chapters

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

4 Chapters

PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

8 Chapters

MAR

AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

6 Chapters

MAR

AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

4 Chapters

PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

11 Chapters

MAR

AM Session

Closings

5 Chapters

PM Session

Closings

7 Chapters

MAR

Recording Disclaimer: This proceeding was recorded in full.

Beatriz Vergara, et al. v. State of California

Summary

Outcome

Sessions

Suggest a Trial

CVN Essentials

Video Library

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:48	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Deasy, Dr. John Ph.D.	In Person
00:33:15	Witness Cross Examination	Finberg, James	Deasy, Dr. John Ph.D.	In Person
01:04:51	Witness Cross Examination	Finberg, James	Deasy, Dr. John Ph.D.	In Person
01:16:44	Break
02:37:49	Break
02:40:44	Witness Cross Examination	Carson, Susan	Deasy, Dr. John Ph.D.	In Person
02:55:14	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:51	Witness Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Bhatka, Bhavini	In Person
00:22:06	Witness Cross Examination	Antonen, Charles	Bhatka, Bhavini	In Person
00:48:09	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Bhatka, Bhavini	In Person
00:54:23	Witness Re-Cross Examination	Antonen, Charles	Bhatka, Bhavini	In Person
00:55:43	Witness Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Kappenhagen, William	In Person
01:11:56	Break
01:29:33	Witness Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Kappenhagen, William	In Person
02:10:09	Witness Cross Examination	Thoreen, Peder	Kappenhagen, William	In Person
02:27:36	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:01:49	Witness Direct Examination	Boutrous, Theodore "Ted"	Vergara, Beatriz	In Person
00:16:06	Witness Cross Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Vergara, Beatriz	In Person
00:39:12	Witness Direct Examination	Boutrous, Theodore "Ted"	Vergara, Elizabeth	In Person
00:48:37	Witness Cross Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Vergara, Elizabeth	In Person
01:02:06	Break
01:20:04	Witness Cross Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Vergara, Elizabeth	In Person
01:22:13	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Boutrous, Theodore "Ted"	Vergara, Elizabeth	In Person
01:23:17	Witness Re-Cross Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Vergara, Elizabeth	In Person
01:25:39	Witness Direct Examination	Monagas, Enrique	Monterroza, Raylene	In Person
01:43:22	Witness Cross Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Monterroza, Raylene	In Person
01:59:08	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:02:09	Witness Cross Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Monterroza, Raylene	In Person
00:07:28	General Case Activities
00:24:11	Witness Direct Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Melvoin, Nicholas	In Person
00:50:48	Witness Cross Examination	Weissglass, Jonathan	Melvoin, Nicholas	In Person
00:58:52	Witness Cross Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Melvoin, Nicholas	In Person
01:01:48	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Melvoin, Nicholas	In Person
01:03:03	General Case Activities
01:05:38	Break
01:25:10	Witness Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Goldhaber, Dr. Dan Ph.D.	In Person
02:18:08	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:11:55	Witness Cross Examination	Finberg, James	Goldhaber, Dr. Dan Ph.D.	In Person
00:18:55	Break
00:22:13	Witness Cross Examination	Finberg, James	Goldhaber, Dr. Dan Ph.D.	In Person
00:57:26	Witness Cross Examination	Carson, Susan	Goldhaber, Dr. Dan Ph.D.	In Person
01:04:00	Break
01:20:22	Witness Cross Examination	Carson, Susan	Goldhaber, Dr. Dan Ph.D.	In Person
01:36:24	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Goldhaber, Dr. Dan Ph.D.	In Person
01:44:47	Witness Re-Cross Examination	Carson, Susan	Goldhaber, Dr. Dan Ph.D.	In Person
01:45:45	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Goldhaber, Dr. Dan Ph.D.	In Person
01:46:39	Witness Re-Cross Examination	Carson, Susan	Goldhaber, Dr. Dan Ph.D.	In Person
01:49:37	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Ramanathan, Dr. Arun Ph.D.	In Person
01:59:10	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:01:22	Witness Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Jacobs, Sandi	In Person
00:48:24	Break
01:05:24	Witness Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Jacobs, Sandi	In Person
01:20:52	Witness Cross Examination	Bunshoft, Jennifer	Jacobs, Sandi	In Person
01:37:43	Witness Cross Examination	Thoreen, Peder	Jacobs, Sandi	In Person
01:45:50	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Withers, Kyle	Jacobs, Sandi	In Person
01:48:12	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:06:44	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Fekete, Frank	In Person
01:22:07	Break
01:40:00	Witness Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Fekete, Frank	In Person
02:00:33	Witness Cross Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Fekete, Frank	In Person
02:27:11	Witness Cross Examination	Carson, Susan	Fekete, Frank	In Person
02:44:14	Witness Re-Direct Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Fekete, Frank	In Person
02:49:06	General Case Activities
02:53:08	End of Session

			Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
		00:00:00	General Case Activities
		00:43:51	Break
		00:52:49	General Case Activities
		01:13:12	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:02:13	Witness Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Fraisse, Dr. Robert Ph.D.	In Person
00:53:12	Break
01:03:58	Witness Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Fraisse, Dr. Robert Ph.D.	In Person
01:56:45	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:01:11	Witness Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Fraisse, Dr. Robert Ph.D.	In Person
00:37:21	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Fraisse, Dr. Robert Ph.D.	In Person
01:16:21	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Fraisse, Dr. Robert Ph.D.	In Person
01:21:16	General Case Activities	McRae, Marcellus	Fraisse, Dr. Robert Ph.D.	In Person
01:23:28	Break
01:38:57	Witness Re-Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Fraisse, Dr. Robert Ph.D.	In Person
01:52:02	Witness Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	McLaughlin, Christine	In Person
01:54:56	Break
02:01:59	Witness Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	McLaughlin, Christine	In Person
02:44:09	Break
02:48:37	General Case Activities
02:51:17	Witness Cross Examination	Monagas, Enrique	McLaughlin, Christine	In Person
02:53:49	General Case Activities
02:57:36	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:21	Witness Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Barrera, Richard	In Person
00:17:50	Witness Cross Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Barrera, Richard	In Person
00:41:27	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Barrera, Richard	In Person
00:43:14	General Case Activities
00:46:43	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:47	Witness Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Mills, Susan	In Person
00:04:50	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Mills, Susan	In Person
00:30:26	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Mills, Susan	In Person
00:32:29	Witness Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Boyd, Walter	In Person
00:54:04	Witness Cross Examination	Withers, Kyle	Boyd, Walter	In Person
01:04:34	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Rothner, Glenn	Boyd, Walter	In Person
01:04:51	Break
01:13:38	Witness Direct Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Brown, Danette	In Person
01:30:08	Break
01:45:14	Witness Direct Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Brown, Danette	In Person
02:20:41	Witness Cross Examination	Lipshutz, Joshua	Brown, Danette	In Person
02:36:16	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Goldsmith, Eileen	Brown, Danette	In Person
02:37:52	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:53	Witness Direct Examination	Thoreen, Peder	Brown, Shannan	In Person
00:58:46	Break
01:14:52	General Case Activities
01:15:29	Witness Direct Examination	Thoreen, Peder	Brown, Shannan	In Person
01:18:07	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Brown, Shannan	In Person
01:56:52	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:38	Witness Direct Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Purdue, Roxanne	In Person
00:16:35	Break
00:26:25	Witness Direct Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Purdue, Roxanne	In Person
01:18:33	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Purdue, Roxanne	In Person
01:25:16	Break
01:41:20	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Purdue, Roxanne	In Person
01:56:06	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Purdue, Roxanne	In Person
01:59:23	General Case Activities
02:01:10	Witness Direct Examination	Hsiao, Constance	Jawitz-McClellen, Joshua	In Person
02:07:30	Break
02:09:41	General Case Activities
02:11:46	Witness Direct Examination	Hsiao, Constance	Jawitz-McClellen, Joshua	In Person
02:17:40	End of Session
03:12:49	General Case Activities

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:10:54	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Nichols, Lynda	In Person
00:43:00	Break
00:47:54	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Elias, Nimrod	Nichols, Lynda	In Person
00:57:12	Break
01:14:24	General Case Activities
01:15:12	Witness Direct Examination	Antonen, Charles	Futernick, Dr. Ken Ph.D.	In Person
01:56:48	End of Session

	Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:17:29	Witness Direct Examination	Weissglass, Jonathan	Ekchian, Vivian	In Person
00:45:00	Break
00:58:02	Witness Cross Examination	McRae, Marcellus	Ekchian, Vivian	In Person
01:21:04	General Case Activities
01:28:09	End of Session

	Description	Attorney
00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:02:24	Closing Statement	Boutrous, Theodore "Ted"
00:43:18	Break
00:59:35	Closing Statement	McRae, Marcellus
01:55:57	End of Session